Do frost lines where studs are on a wall show a failure of spray foam insulation?

Gerald Crozier Published: July 22, 2019, 10:24 p.m.Last updated: Dec. 1, 2019, 4:16 p.m.

I have a customer with frost problems whose home shows every stud from the outside on a winter day. Would you say their spray foam insulation has failed?

Responses (1)

Mike Reynolds July 29, 2019, 10:26 a.m. Reply

It's hard to ever weigh in on a problem with complete confidence without seeing a project or knowing the full wall assembly, but if anything, that may actually show a 'success' of the spray foam rather than a failure. The wood studs will transfer far more heat than the Spray Polyurethane Foam (SPUF), so what you are seeing could actually be an indication of how important it is to include seamless insulation in a wall assembly.

The best method of wood frame construction would always include continuous insulation on the exterior of walls, without that you may see indications of thermal bridging through studs in the form of frost lines. The temperature on the exterior of the wall where the studs are would be higher than the temperature adjacent to the stud bays since they are filled with spray foam (SPUF), and so it may melt the frost.

Feel free to send us more details or pics of the wall. I am also a bit curious as to how it showed the studs from the outside if there siding installed with an air space, is the wall still under construction and it was frost forming on the exterior sheathing?

Professional services

Related Advice

What do you think of insulated T Studs in Canada?

Posted by Lee Watt June 3, 2019, 10:57 a.m. Wall assemblies - new construction 1 Responses

Can I spray foam insulate from the outside?

Posted by Kurt Klischuk June 6, 2019, 8:56 a.m. Wall assemblies - renovation 1 Responses

How do you build a mold-free basement in a new construction house?

Posted by Charmaine Herzig Feb. 10, 2020, 7:32 p.m. Basements improvements 3 Responses

Can you Insulate a Cinder block basement foundation with Rockwool?

Posted by Victor B June 19, 2019, 11:41 p.m. Basements improvements 5 Responses

What do I in my basement where new insulation meets old?

Posted by Steve J July 20, 2019, 10:01 p.m. Basements improvements 2 Responses

What is the best way to frame window openings when adding exterior insulation?

Posted by Anwas Qwelten May 30, 2019, 8:16 p.m. Windows and doors 1 Responses

|s there thermal bridging in the Edelweiss REMOTE wall?

Posted by David Pantalone Feb. 9, 2020, 4:42 p.m. Wall assemblies - new construction 1 Responses

Can you spray foam a house from the outside?

Posted by Joan Lawrence July 11, 2019, 7:17 p.m. Wall assemblies - renovation 3 Responses

Can I add Larsen Trusses and cellulose to 1920s House in Minneapolis?

Posted by Ken Traefald Feb. 17, 2020, 2:30 p.m. Wall assemblies - renovation 3 Responses

Can you use Foam boards on basement walls to stop condensation?

Posted by Chad Johnson Dec. 21, 2019, 7:59 p.m. Basements improvements 3 Responses

For home renovation, is it better to install insulation on the inside or outside?

Posted by Neil Richardson Jan. 29, 2019, 4:09 p.m. Wall assemblies - renovation 1 Responses

Basement reno - How do I effectively insulate my basement?

Posted by Steve J Feb. 13, 2019, 10:25 p.m. Foundation and basement improvements 2 Responses

How do you fix a moisture problem in a finished basement?

Posted by Margo MACFARLANE Oct. 28, 2019, 10:24 a.m. Foundation and basement improvements 1 Responses

Can you use polyiso insulation on the exterior of a wall behind cedar siding on the west coast?

Posted by Iain Matheson Jan. 28, 2020, 10:38 p.m. Wall assemblies - renovation 1 Responses

Combo structural sheathing, WRB and thin insulation panel in Ontario?

Posted by Steve Bull Jan. 14, 2020, 6:06 p.m. Walls and Roofs 3 Responses

Can I put a breathable peel and stick weather (air) barrier on the inside walls and ceiling?

Posted by Anomika Singhn Oct. 1, 2018, 9:56 p.m. Air and vapour barriers 1 Responses

I want to insulate the outside of my house, which type of insulation do you think is best?

Posted by Joe F Nov. 15, 2017, 10:34 a.m. Wall assemblies - renovation 7 Responses

What is the best way to insulate the basement of an old house?

Posted by Bryan Squirrell Jan. 14, 2020, 7:59 p.m. Basements improvements 1 Responses

How do you remove moisture and condensation from basement walls?

Posted by Aaron Keating July 27, 2019, 4:51 p.m. Basements improvements 3 Responses

What is the best way to insulate a home from the outside?

Posted by Sylvie Gagnon Dec. 12, 2017, 11:58 a.m. Wall assemblies - renovation 1 Responses

How do you prevent walls from rotting in humid climates?

Posted by Rose Alderson Nov. 5, 2018, 4:34 p.m. Wall assemblies - new construction 1 Responses

Which exterior insulation is best to create at thermal break in an bungalow in Alberta?

Posted by Rebekah Barnes Jan. 17, 2020, 10:07 p.m. Wall assemblies - renovation 1 Responses

How do you do a Vapour Barrier in a Dense Pack Cellulose Wall?

Posted by Ian MacKay July 26, 2018, 2:48 p.m. Wall assemblies - renovation 4 Responses

How do you seal windows from the exterior for water and air but not create a vapor seal?

Posted by Piyush Prince Nov. 7, 2018, 12:10 a.m. Windows and doors 1 Responses

Is EPS or XPS better for use in basement rim joists? Should faced or unfaced foam boards be used?

Posted by Thomas Dispenza Sept. 8, 2019, 12:43 a.m. Basements improvements 6 Responses

Related Guide

Efficient home design

What is a thermal bridge and why is it so important to break it?

Thermal bridges in walls can reduce the overall performance of a home. Thermal breaks are the answer to this problem… It is easy to look at the R value rating …

Healthy indoor air quality

Basement renovations: How to prevent mold when finishing basements

Why are basements moldy? Because we build walls so they can't dry. Simple changes in wall design will result in mould-free durable basements… Basements don't h…

Wall assemblies - new construction

Choosing a building envelope - starting with the perfect wall

When it comes to choosing a building envelope there are many variables to consider: what climate zone you're building in, performance, durability, health, comf…

Insulation and soundproofing

Best practices for basement insulation in new home construction

Basements in Canada & USA face serious challenges: fluctuating water tables, surface floods, thermal shock, radon gas infiltration, condensation, mold, mildew,…

Healthy indoor air quality

Why are basements moldy? How to fix or Prevent a Moldy Basement

Basement mold and mildew can easily be avoided with better designed walls. Common building practices trap moisture in wall assemblies preventing them from dryi…

Walls and Roofs

The easiest way to insulate walls from the exterior in older homes

Fitting extra insulation to an older home when renovating can be a great idea, but when insulating exterior walls from the outside take care to do it right. Ec…

Concept and design

Building science for LEED v4 wall design made easy - video

Understanding building science basics will help you design and build durable and efficient wall systems, in this instance LEED Platinum v4… LEED Platinum V4 Wa…

Related Advice

What do you think of insulated T Studs in Canada?

Can I spray foam insulate from the outside?

How do you build a mold-free basement in a new construction house?

Can you Insulate a Cinder block basement foundation with Rockwool?

What do I in my basement where new insulation meets old?

What is the best way to frame window openings when adding exterior insulation?

|s there thermal bridging in the Edelweiss REMOTE wall?

Can you spray foam a house from the outside?

Related Guide

What is a thermal bridge and why is it so important to break it?

Basement renovations: How to prevent mold when finishing basements

Choosing a building envelope - starting with the perfect wall

Best practices for basement insulation in new home construction

Why are basements moldy? How to fix or Prevent a Moldy Basement

The easiest way to insulate walls from the exterior in older homes

Building science for LEED v4 wall design made easy - video

Dense-packed cellulose insulation wall systems

Latest posts

Gabion Walls - what is a gabion cage & how to build with them?

Lasagna Gardening: the pros & cons of a lasagna garden

Why you should get an E-bike now

Lasagna gardening - the easiest vegetable garden at home?

Do frost lines where studs are on a wall show a failure of spray foam insulation?

Responses (1)

Related Advice

What do you think of insulated T Studs in Canada?

Can I spray foam insulate from the outside?

How do you build a mold-free basement in a new construction house?

Can you Insulate a Cinder block basement foundation with Rockwool?

What do I in my basement where new insulation meets old?

What is the best way to frame window openings when adding exterior insulation?

|s there thermal bridging in the Edelweiss REMOTE wall?

Can you spray foam a house from the outside?

Related Guide

What is a thermal bridge and why is it so important to break it?

Basement renovations: How to prevent mold when finishing basements

Choosing a building envelope - starting with the perfect wall

Best practices for basement insulation in new home construction

Why are basements moldy? How to fix or Prevent a Moldy Basement

The easiest way to insulate walls from the exterior in older homes

Building science for LEED v4 wall design made easy - video

Dense-packed cellulose insulation wall systems

Latest posts

Gabion Walls - what is a gabion cage & how to build with them?

Lasagna Gardening: the pros & cons of a lasagna garden

Why you should get an E-bike now

Lasagna gardening - the easiest vegetable garden at home?

Responses (1)

Related products

Professional services

Related Advice

What do you think of insulated T Studs in Canada?

Can I spray foam insulate from the outside?

How do you build a mold-free basement in a new construction house?

Can you Insulate a Cinder block basement foundation with Rockwool?

What do I in my basement where new insulation meets old?

What is the best way to frame window openings when adding exterior insulation?

|s there thermal bridging in the Edelweiss REMOTE wall?

Can you spray foam a house from the outside?

Can I add Larsen Trusses and cellulose to 1920s House in Minneapolis?

Can you use Foam boards on basement walls to stop condensation?

For home renovation, is it better to install insulation on the inside or outside?

Basement reno - How do I effectively insulate my basement?

How do you fix a moisture problem in a finished basement?

Can you use polyiso insulation on the exterior of a wall behind cedar siding on the west coast?

Combo structural sheathing, WRB and thin insulation panel in Ontario?

Can I put a breathable peel and stick weather (air) barrier on the inside walls and ceiling?

I want to insulate the outside of my house, which type of insulation do you think is best?

What is the best way to insulate the basement of an old house?

How do you remove moisture and condensation from basement walls?

What is the best way to insulate a home from the outside?

How do you prevent walls from rotting in humid climates?

Which exterior insulation is best to create at thermal break in an bungalow in Alberta?

How do you do a Vapour Barrier in a Dense Pack Cellulose Wall?

How do you seal windows from the exterior for water and air but not create a vapor seal?

Is EPS or XPS better for use in basement rim joists? Should faced or unfaced foam boards be used?

Related Guide

What is a thermal bridge and why is it so important to break it?

Basement renovations: How to prevent mold when finishing basements

Choosing a building envelope - starting with the perfect wall

Best practices for basement insulation in new home construction

Why are basements moldy? How to fix or Prevent a Moldy Basement

The easiest way to insulate walls from the exterior in older homes

Building science for LEED v4 wall design made easy - video