Related Advice
Related Guide
Related News
Latest posts
Responses (2)
Related Searches
Related products
Related Advice
Does hydronic radiant cooling work?
Posted by dean c
April 30, 2019, 8:01 p.m.
Delivery: radiant, forced-air and decentralized
1 Responses
Can hydronic radiant heating be a complete heating solution for a home?
Posted by Jeremy Peters
Dec. 16, 2019, 1:13 a.m.
Delivery: radiant, forced-air and decentralized
3 Responses
What is the best type of radiant floor heating for a garage?
Posted by J.F.
March 24, 2017, 11:14 a.m.
Delivery: radiant, forced-air and decentralized
1 Responses
Would you recommend Legalett over water radiant floor heat for a backyard studio in Toronto?
Posted by Christine Pountney
May 2, 2019, 1:22 p.m.
Delivery: radiant, forced-air and decentralized
1 Responses
How could I convert my hydronic gas heated floors to electric heated floors?
Posted by Betty Potter-Collins
June 7, 2020, 8:20 p.m.
Delivery: radiant, forced-air and decentralized
2 Responses
What heating system to use in my new detached garage/shop?
Posted by David Perreault
Dec. 4, 2020, 10:23 a.m.
Delivery: radiant, forced-air and decentralized
0 Responses
What is better for a small slab on grade foundation: water (glycol) or electrical radiant heat?
Posted by Mark Dixon
July 7, 2020, 2:56 p.m.
Delivery: radiant, forced-air and decentralized
3 Responses
Is hydronic slab heat appropriate in a super insulated home?
Posted by Andrew Wright
Feb. 3, 2021, 3:26 p.m.
Delivery: radiant, forced-air and decentralized
1 Responses
Which radiant floor heat is best?
Posted by tony wolff
Dec. 25, 2020, 1:22 p.m.
Delivery: radiant, forced-air and decentralized
3 Responses
We want to build a solarium in Ontario, what do you think of heating it with a radiant floor and wood stove?
Posted by Deanna Zavattin-Tortolo
Feb. 18, 2020, 10:51 p.m.
Greenhouses and Sunrooms / Solariums
1 Responses
What are the options for radiant heat with a slab on grade?
Posted by August Wehrmann
Feb. 3, 2019, 6:52 p.m.
Delivery: radiant, forced-air and decentralized
1 Responses
Thanks for your question, and I would start here in general terms of efficiency in heat delivery - there is no great difference in the energy efficiency between air heated floors or hydronic (liquid) radiant floors, at least when they are heated with the same fuel. Meaning – a boiler heating water that is circulated through radiant tubing in a concrete floor will not be any more or less efficient that a boiler heating a water coil that blows air through a floor.
The fuel source (gas, electricity, propane etc) will affect cost and efficiency, but differences in how you deliver heat isn’t as big a factor in determining efficiency. This page discusses the differences and pros and cons of each system –
Radiant floors heated with air tubes
Moving into a solar solution though and choosing between a solar water heater and a solar air heater, there you would for sure have more variables in terms of the initial cost of the system, return on investment time, maintenance and lifespan.
I assume you saw our page on solar air heated radiant slab on grade floor. I would personally lean towards that because they address a lot of the issues that come up with solar thermal water heaters – read more here, which can have a lot of maintenance issues. The thermal solar air panels we installed in that prefab kit house obviously don’t leak water, freezing is not a concern, and even summer overheating has been solved because that system has been adapted to generate solar hot water in summer in part to cool the system.
Solar thermal water heaters can, in a bizarre twist, need to be covered often during summer to avoid overheating. I hope this helps, check out those pages and if you have more questions let us know, but include your climate zone as well and we can better help you decide.
Thanks for the response, I am in a zone 4a just off the southern end of Georgian Bay we get lots of snow in winter with many days a -20c and days as low as -30c we also get wet cold off of the lakes, summertime temperatures often above 25c and humid. I have built many ICF homes over the years most with hydronic floors, the biggest problems I have run into is with homeowners topping up with well water and having lime scale buildup in boilers or finishing basements after the fact and piercing tubing, to prevent the later I have move to 5" concrete floors. I have found that by placing hydronic panels on wall under over hangs reduces the need to cover panels in the summer. Always curious about advancements in housing tech